Self and peer assessment advantages and disadvantages. Student assessments diagnostic assessment advantages and. Traditional assessment forces educators to spend time teaching students how to manage tests, including strategies for selecting correct answers from a listed group. Portfolio assessment is also a systematic collection of student work and related. However, there are some major disadvantages of portfolio use. The usefulness of portfolios as assessment tools in higher education. There are several advantages and disadvantages of project portfolio management so its importantfadvantage to understand if this is the right process for your organization before making a move. Abstractearly childhood n 10 and firstgrade teachers n 10 views concerning portfolio usage were investigated in the current research.
Serves as a concrete vehicle for communication, providing ongoing communication or exchanges of information among those involved in assessment. Advantages and disadvantages of eportfolios due to the fact that eportfolios offer great opportunities, many advantages of eportfolios can be mentioned. Another advantage of using the portfolio assessment is the fact that students are taught. In the past, portfolios were presented in binders, but electronicor eportfoliosare becoming more common. While projects can be valuable classroom tools, they do have some disadvantages. By learning the disadvantages of each method, you can choose how you want your professional samples displayed as you seek job opportunities. There are advantages and disadvantages to both structured portfolios and to more openended portfolios. When deciding which activity to be used, both the intended learning outcomes and the learning activities need. The above listed are few advantages and disadvantages of summative evaluation. What are the advantages and disadvantages of a diversified. In this connection i would like you to read the introduction of the source book on evaluation available in the website of ncert. Advantages and disadvantages of online assessments. Educators strive to use various types of authentic assessments with their students. There are several drawbacks to using student portfolios to evaluate a student bodys learning when trying to gather accurate information at a college.
A performancebased assessment measures a students ability to apply the skills learned in an authentic way and determines strengths or highlights a particular skill. Advantages and disadvantages of eportfolios new media. Further, to exploit portfolio assessment method effectively some suggestions were made. Reduces or eliminates faculty time demands in instrument development and grading. A professional portfolio is a collection of documents highlighting your achievements, training, education and skills. Selfevaluations advantages of portfolio assessment promoting. Portfolio it is a form of alternative assessment intended to accumulate evidence to measure growth over time of a students or teachers performance. Doc advantages of portfolio assessment joe zen academia.
One is that it can be very demanding for students, parents, teachers andor. The usefulness of portfolios as assessment tools in higher. Some schools even use portfolio assessment as a basis for high school graduation. Data collected as descriptive information, such as a narrative or portfolio. One of the first researchers to use the term authentic assessment, dr. It can be extremely valuable in helping students develop selfreflection, critique and judgment and ultimately, students learn how to be responsible for their own learning.
Many other disadvantages can be remedied, though, so projects will increase comprehension and overall student learning. The disadvantages of performancebased assessment the classroom. Advantages and disadvantages of various assessment methods. What are the advantages and disadvantages of portfolio. One type of assessment is the portfolio, and this lesson describes what a portfolio is, what goes in it, and how. Summative evaluation advantages and disadvantages wisestep. The research presented in this article attempts to capture the views of teachers of elementary education about the advantages, disadvantages, difficulties and obstacles in the application of the portal as a rating and selfevaluation tool by the. This paper defines portfolio as a selfassessment and selfreflection tool with its various types. Advantages and disadvantages of various assessment methods 1. Portfolios with prescribed structures are evident in programmes leading to a pro fessional qualification or an academic award where the portfolio forms part of the assessment of these programmes. Benefits outweigh extrawork fears each week, an educator takes a stand or shares an aha. Mar 01, 2020 foreign portfolio investment occurs when a nonresident of a foreign country participates in a crossborder transaction with the aim of purchasing securities, cash equivalents, or other portfolio.
Nevertheless, portfolios as an evaluative measure of student learning pose drawbacks. Not much can be said about the disadvantages of online assessments, since the advantages outweigh them by far. Pdf challenges of using portfolio assessment as an alternative. In order to understand it, better one should look at the advantages and disadvantages of exams advantages of exams competitive.
What are the advantages of authentic assessment over. In the classroom, a portfolio provides a student with the chance to show off his best work in one place. The advantages of portfolio assessments a portfolio is a systematic collection of a students work and related materials that allows a teacher or potential employer to comprehensively assess and evaluate the students activities, accomplishments and achievements. After collecting the data, six themes were constituted regarding the teachers opinions about portfolio use concerning portfolio conception, advantages, disadvantages and challenges of portfolios, the content of early childhood. Advantages and disadvantages of classroom projects. The idea of portfolio assessment is to look at various examples of student work over time instead of one socalled snapshot of student work as is typical in most standardized assessment. What are the advantages or disadvantages of portfolio assessment.
The main hindrance for a formative evaluation is that it does not require time and money and hence it is a barrier to undertake it. To begin with, the creation of eportfolios demands a high degree of selforganisation and selfresponsibility. The use of portfolio to assess students performance. The assessment portfolio allows for identifying growth in a concise package. For this reason, alternative assessment approaches are needed in.
Projects work well as assessment tools, but not every student will benefit from every project assigned. The findings of the study revealed that portfolio assessment helped in improving students performance in map sketching and location, where the experimental group recorded higher mean gain scores. This week, educator kathleen modenbach reflects on her use of a streamlined writing portfolio assessment that was beneficial to her and her students and. Disadvantages of portfolio assessment requiring extra time to plan an. What are the advantages of foreign portfolio investment. Pdf advantages and disadvantages of eportfolio implementation. Recommendations for establishing portfolios as an essential component in a. The advantages and disadvantages of portfoliobased assessment are discussed and the parameters, guidelines, and the necessary conditions for implementing a portfoliobased assessment process are examined. A formative assessment is far better in many ways than a summative evaluation and helps in finding out why a program doesnt work.
While each type of portfolio has value, the portfolio assessment has many advantages for students. Advantages and disadvantages for assessment 9,428 views. Advantages and disadvantages of various assessment. These aspects cannot judge if a student knows the subject or not. Instructional approaches on k12 education have changed with the passage of time.
Serves as a crosssection lens, providing a basis for future analysis and planning. Traditional assessments refer to conventional methods of testing, usually standardized and use pen and paper with multiplechoice, true or false or matching type test items. What are some disadvantages of portfolio assessment. Advantages and disadvantages of 14 types of assessment activities there are many different assessment activities used in higher education. The pros and cons of assessing students through portfolios.
In the classroom, a portfolio provides a student with. As with all assessments, there are advantages and disadvantages of performancebased assessments. Jan 25, 2019 traditional assessment also has both advantages and disadvantages when it comes to the way educators teach. Portfolio assessment pros and cons free pdf ebooks. Traditional assessment also has both advantages and disadvantages when it comes to the way educators teach. Portfolios also encourage student selfevaluation and reflection, as well as ownership for learning popham, 2005. In this study, we realized a comparative analysis between the features of the portfolio acknowledged by experts in education and those identified by students, expressed as advantagesdisadvantages. Perhaps there is no single method of assessment which is complete. It is still a question that how a teacher can apply alternative assessment methods properly without having enough knowledge and experience about it. The practices of portfolio assessment should be understood in the context that the above discussion has created.
Portfolio as a learnercentered assessment strategy is based on the. Selfevaluation assessment portfolios require students to continuously reflect and perform selfevaluations of their work. Self and peer assessment advantages and disadvantages group work can be more successful when students are involved in developing the assessment process. Davis and ponnamperuma 2005, for example, hold that portfolios, as a method of learning and assessment, can enhance critical thinking, learner responsibility, interaction between tutor and student, reflection and selfassessment, creativity, as well as professional and personal improvements. Disadvantages of using portfolio assessment it may be seen as less reliable or fair than more quantitative evaluations. Working portfolios contain works in process as well as finished works. This may include establishing their own assessment criteria through consultation with teaching staff.
Advantages of using portfolio assessment sewell serves as a. Alternative assessments simonson and others discussed the disadvantages of. The portfolio gives students the opportunity to have various input into the learning process and to demonstrated knowledge in many different ways. The primary advantage of the portfolio assessment is that it measures performance based on authentic samples of student work. Grant wiggins, says that authentic assessments directly examine student performance on worthy intellectual tasks, present the student with tasks found in the best instructional activities and real life and determine whether the student can craft polished, thorough and justifiable answers, performances or products. Display portfolios showcases students best work and assessment portfolios demonstrate the specific curriculum standards students have learned. Also, portfolio assessment method is compared with traditional one in terms of different aspects. Jul 18, 2015 authentic assessments refer to assessments wherein students are asked to perform realworld tasks that demonstrate meaningful application of what they have learned.
The advantages and disadvantages of portfolio based assessment are discussed and the parameters, guidelines, and the necessary conditions for implementing a portfolio based assessment process are examined. Advantages and disadvantages of eportfolios new media in. Authentic assessments refer to assessments wherein students are asked to perform realworld tasks that demonstrate meaningful application of what they have learned. Portfolio project management encourages people to get involved from every level of the organization. Advantages and disadvantages open textbooks for hong kong. Alternatively you can provide students with sample self andor peer assessment criteria. Teachers and students should gain knowledge of these and try for new steps to avoid disadvantages in the future.
Jun 06, 2011 what should the portfolio demonstrate. Advantages and disadvantages of 14 types of assessment. Using classroom assessment to promote student motivation is an important component of assessment for learning which is considered in the next section. Jun 27, 2012 slides from webinar on eportfolios as assessmentt given by eloise tan in the 2012 online assessment and feedback module at dublin city university. Technological advancements have brought into play greater use of visual aids, hypermedia, and interactive simulations and lesser practice of the traditional chalkboard method. What are the advantages or disadvantages of portfolio. The use of portfolio as an assessment tool international journal. The use of portfolio to assess students performance eric. Describe the advantages of portfolio assessment for students. The research presented in this article attempts to capture the views of teachers of elementary education about the advantages, disadvantages, difficulties and obstacles in the application of the. The pros and cons of an assessment portfolio a portfolio is a collection of work, accumulated over a period of time. A highly diversified portfolio can also be more timeconsuming to manage than a lessdiversified portfolio because youll. Although there are many advantages to having a professional portfolio, there are disadvantages for each version. Describe the advantages of portfolio assessment for.
In commerce, portfolio analysis provides a view of the companys product mix to determine the optimum allocation of resources. Oct 10, 2017 there are several advantages and disadvantages of project portfolio management so its importantfadvantage to understand if this is the right process for your organization before making a move. Advantages and disadvantages of self and peer assessment. What are the advantages and disadvantages of a diversified portfolio. Foreign portfolio investment occurs when a nonresident of a foreign country participates in a crossborder transaction with the aim of purchasing securities, cash equivalents, or other portfolio. But there might be some, for example, you need to be computer literate or able to use a computer well in order to create and take an assessment. First, good portfolio assessment takes an enormous amount of teacher time and organization. The advantages and disadvantages of project portfolio. When deciding which activity to be used, both the intended learning outcomes and the learning activities need to be considered so as to make sure they are all aligned. Becoming reflective students and teachers with portfolios and authentic assessment. Advantages and disadvantages of classroom projects synonym.
Standardized assessment 1 a standardized test is any form of test that 1 requires all test takers to answer the same questions, or a selection of questions from common bank of questions, in the same way, and that 2 is scored in a standard or consistent manner, which makes it possible to compare the relative performance of individual students or groups of students. The time is needed to help students understand the purpose and structure of the portfolio, decide which work samples to collect, and to self reflect. An assessment portfolio is a compilation of a student s authentic work over a particular period. Exams have been going for past many decades but from past few years, people have been questioning the utility of exams for every course as according to them exam should not be the only barometer of performance. Connections between portfolio and real world applications jobhigher ed. Portfolio analysis is valuable in commerce and investing. The collection of work includes grading guidelines, the rational for the evaluations chosen, and allow for selfawareness. Definition of eportfolios jisc, 2008an eportfolio is theproduct, created by the the picture has oftenlearner, a been a complexcollection of digital one, with confusionartefacts. Standardized exams commercial advantages convenient can be adopted and implemented quickly.
1520 541 1224 851 523 1335 1079 1396 488 108 518 1023 251 1145 27 800 1349 334 304 1001 1537 1189 375 431 1117 1299 710 146 1493 1240 477 800